Jackpot Dreaming home

Who Owns Arizona's $12.8M Lottery Ticket?

A Scottsdale Circle K printed a $12.8M The Pick winner nobody paid for before the draw. Who owns it under Arizona rules, and what to do first.

Jackpot Dreaming Editorial6 min read

A brass ticket box with blank cream cards sits on linen beside a deep red velvet pouch and scattered gold coins, warm soft morning light

News summary based on court filings and reporting cited below — not a prediction of who will win the lawsuit. Jackpot Dreaming is a personal project and is not affiliated with any lottery.

What happened at the Scottsdale Circle K

According to reporting on Circle K's complaint, on Nov. 24, 2025 a customer walked into a Circle K on Bell Road in Scottsdale and asked for about $85 worth of tickets for The Pick, Arizona's in-state draw game. The clerk printed them. The customer paid for only $60. The rest — about 25 tickets in early accounts — sat unsold at the store.

That evening, one of those unsold tickets matched all six numbers and hit a jackpot reported at $12.8 million.

The next morning, store manager Robert Gawlitza learned the store had generated the winner. Court papers say he found the unsold tickets, confirmed the numbers, clocked out, removed his uniform, and had coworker Marline Ybarra ring up a $10 sale. He got a receipt. He and Ybarra both signed the back. Circle K later held the ticket at corporate and, according to Gawlitza's side, fired him when he tried to claim.

Circle K filed a declaratory judgment case in Maricopa County Superior Court asking who owns the ticket. Gawlitza's attorney, Josh Kolsrud, argues he followed store practice for leftover tickets and that ownership transferred on the completed sale. By mid-2026, filings had named the original customer — who asked Phoenix New Times to call her Anna Kim — as someone with a possible claim, and listed Ybarra as a defendant staking her own interest. Kim had not joined the suit in that reporting. In September 2026, coverage noted employee affidavits about unpaid-ticket practices; Circle K has moved to dismiss Gawlitza's counterclaims.

What Arizona Lottery rules say

Two regulations sit at the center of the fight.

Retailer ownership of refused, unsold draw tickets. Under Ariz. Admin. Code § R19-3-213(D)(1), if a retailer generates a draw ticket a player refuses (or accepts a returned one) and does not resell it, the Lottery deems the ticket owned by the retailer. Retailers pay for tickets they print whether or not a customer walks out with them. That default reading is why several reports say the rules favor Circle K for a ticket that sat unsold through the draw.

Signature and possession. Under Ariz. Admin. Code § R19-3-406, until a ticket is signed it belongs to its physical possessor. Once signed, the owner is the person whose signature appears in the designated area. Multiple signatures can force the Lottery to designate who gets paid. That is why Gawlitza's (and Ybarra's) signatures matter — and why a post-draw "sale" of a ticket the retailer may already have owned is the hard question for the court.

AZ Central's February 2026 explainer noted Arizona Lottery rules do not broadly ban employees from buying tickets; they do spell out refused, unsold inventory. Internal retailer policy is a separate fight from Lottery regulation.

Why the claim clock was paused

Arizona winners normally have 180 days from the drawing to claim. For a Nov. 24, 2025 draw, that pointed to about May 23, 2026. Phoenix New Times later reported the Arizona Lottery waived that deadline so ownership can be decided. Until then, the $12.8 million remains with the Arizona Lottery. Unclaimed prizes are not theoretical: coverage of the early filings cited a $14.6 million Arizona ticket that went unclaimed in 2019.

Lessons that travel beyond one store

You do not need a Powerball ticket for ownership fights to wreck a win. Office pools, couples, and "I paid for half" deals blow up for the same reasons: unclear payment, unsigned tickets, no written agreement. See our piece on splitting a jackpot with an office pool.

A short checklist if you ever hold a real winner:

  1. Only keep tickets you paid for. Settle overprints before you leave.
  2. Sign the back as soon as you buy. Unsigned tickets travel with whoever holds them.
  3. Photograph both sides and store the original safely. Do not post the full ticket online.
  4. Do not rush the claim. Use the window to hire a tax attorney or CPA and a fiduciary advisor, and to think about privacy. In Arizona, winners of $100,000 or more can ask to keep their names confidential (their city and county of residence are not); rules vary by state. More on trusts for privacy.
  5. Model taxes before you celebrate. Federal withholding on big prizes is only a down payment. Start with the after-tax calculator, then confirm with pros — especially for lump sum versus annuity.

While this case winds through court, the multi-state boards keep climbing. As of the morning of Oct. 9, 2026, Powerball's advertised jackpot is $516 million (cash value $212.6 million) for the Saturday, Oct. 10 drawing, and Mega Millions is estimated at $364 million (cash value $147.3 million) for the Friday, Oct. 9 drawing. Big billboard numbers do not change the first rule: the ticket in your hand has to be yours under the selling lottery's rules.

FAQ

Who owns a lottery ticket that was printed but never paid for?

It depends on the selling lottery. In Arizona, a draw ticket generated for a player, refused, and not resold is generally deemed owned by the retailer. Check your state's rules — and never leave unpaid tickets overnight.

Does signing the back make me the owner?

In Arizona, an unsigned ticket belongs to whoever holds it; a signed ticket points payment at the signature. Signing is still the first move winners are told to make. It does not fix a sale a court later finds invalid.

Can a store employee buy a winning ticket?

Arizona Lottery rules do not broadly forbid employee purchases, but retailer policies and on-duty rules can. Buying a ticket you already know is a winner after the draw is exactly the fact pattern that invites a lawsuit.

How long do Arizona winners have to claim?

Generally 180 days from the drawing. In this dispute the Lottery waived that deadline so the court can decide ownership. Always confirm the window for your game and state.

How much of $12.8 million would someone keep after taxes?

It depends on cash versus annuity options, filing status, and other income. Large lottery prizes are taxed as ordinary income near the top federal rate after 24% withholding. Run a first pass in the Jackpot Dreaming calculator and have a CPA confirm before you claim.

What should I do in the first day with a real winner?

Sign it, photograph it, secure it, tell almost no one, and call a tax attorney or sudden-wealth advisor before you claim. Get written agreements if anyone else helped pay.

Sources

Related guides